Key points
- The Himachal Pradesh High Court rejected the appeal of 53 Senior Lab Technicians on October 6.
- The court ruled that state governments are not legally required to adopt the pay scales of other states.
- The technicians had sought a pay scale equivalent to that of Senior Lab Technicians in Punjab, based on the 1978 Revised Pay Scale.
The Himachal Pradesh High Court dismissed an appeal from 53 Senior Lab Technicians who sought a pay scale matching that of their counterparts in Punjab. The decision, delivered on October 6, upholds a previous single-judge ruling against the technicians’ claim.
A division bench of the High Court, comprising Chief Justice Gurmeet Singh Sandhawalia and Justice Bipin Chandra Negi, stated that no state government is legally bound to follow the pay scales or rules of another. The court described determining a pay scale as a policy decision.
The Senior Lab Technicians had petitioned for the 1978 Revised Pay Scale as implemented in Punjab. They argued for parity, but the court found their claim unsustainable.
In its ruling, the High Court cited several factors relevant to pay scale determination. These included recruitment methods, qualifications required for the role, promotion opportunities available, the nature of duties performed, and the government’s financial capacity.
The court also referenced a recent case involving Cooperative Department Inspectors, noting its similarity to the present matter. This earlier ruling had also addressed the issue of adopting pay scales from other states.
The Himachal Pradesh Government opposed the appeal, citing Article 309 of the Constitution. The government had previously revised the grade pay for Senior Lab Technicians to ₹3,600 through a notification issued in 2013.