Key points
- The Himachal Pradesh High Court ruled that reserved category candidates scoring above the general cutoff can be moved to General Category seats.
- The court ordered the appointment of Krishna Kumar after transferring two SC (BPL) candidates to the general list.
- The ruling involved recruitment for 425 TGT Arts posts announced on May 27, 2025.
The Himachal Pradesh High Court ruled that reserved category candidates who score higher than the cutoff for the General Category in a recruitment exam can be transferred to general category seats.
Justice Jyotsna Revale Dua ordered the Himachal Pradesh State Selection Commission to transfer two SC (BPL) candidates from the reserved list to the General Category.
This order frees up a seat for the petitioner, Krishna Kumar, who was at the top of the waiting list in the SC (BPL) category. The court ordered the commission to appoint Krishna Kumar to a post.
The case involved recruitment for 425 TGT Arts posts announced on May 27, 2025. In this drive, the General Category had 151 posts and the SC (BPL) category had 17 posts reserved.

The general category cutoff was 67.61 marks. Three SC (BPL) candidates scored higher than this, with marks of 75.24, 73.06, and 71.86.
Krishna Kumar scored 64 marks in the SC (BPL) category. The selection commission had previously refused to transfer candidates with higher marks than the general cutoff to general seats, placing them on reserved seats instead.
The commission had sought to apply a 2014 directive from the Department of Personnel that barred merit-based transfer in horizontal reservation. The court rejected this 2014 directive as invalid for merit-based transfers.
The court rejected the argument that horizontal reservation does not allow merit-based transfer to the General Category. It held that a reserved category candidate who scores higher than the general category cutoff is entitled to a general category seat.