Courts Shimla

High Court quashes PWD Engineer-in-Chief’s extension

The court ordered the state government to revive the screening committee process to fill the post by November 11, 2026.

Key points

  • The Himachal Pradesh High Court quashed the extension of PWD Engineer-in-Chief Narinder Pal Singh, calling it illegal.
  • The court ordered the state government to complete the screening committee process for the post by November 11, 2026.
  • The court observed that the promotion process was deliberately deferred to grant an extension without plausible reason.

The Himachal Pradesh High Court has quashed the extension granted to Narinder Pal Singh as Engineer-in-Chief (ENC) of the Public Works Department (PWD). A division bench comprising Justice Vivek Singh Thakur and Justice Ranjan Sharma called the extension illegal, arbitrary, and void ab initio.

The court directed Narinder Pal Singh to relinquish the post of Engineer-in-Chief immediately. It further ordered the state government to revive, convene, and conclude the screening committee process initiated in April 2026 for filling the post.

The court stated that this selection process must be completed by November 11, 2026. If the petitioner, Narinder Paul Singh Chauhan, is found suitable and recommended for promotion, he will be promoted to the post of ENC effective from May 1, 2026.

Such a promotion would include all consequential benefits, including seniority and pay arrears. The court also stated that the principle of 'no work, no pay' will not apply in this case.

The court observed that the promotion process was deliberately deferred and scuttled to grant an extension to the incumbent ENC. It noted that the extension was granted without any plausible reason, justifiable reason, or public interest.

The court observed that the extension was granted despite a written order issued by the state government on April 7, 2026, which prohibited service extensions or re-employment for retired employees. The court noted that the state government ignored its own order.

The court further observed that no record or document proved the extension was granted under extraordinary circumstances. It noted that the proposal for the extension came from the Chief Minister's office rather than lower levels of the department.

Narinder Paul Singh Chauhan had pleaded that he fulfilled all criteria for promotion, including 28 years of service, and that the post must be filled strictly according to policy and procedure.