Government & policy Shimla

High Court halts NHAI tunnel work in Shimla over safety concerns

Justice Sandeep Sharma questioned the decision to build a tunnel through a densely populated area despite an advisory against it.

Key points

  • The Himachal Pradesh High Court ordered NHAI to stop construction of the twin-tube tunnel in Shimla due to safety risks to houses.
  • The court questioned the loss of ₹600 crore spent on land acquisition for a surface highway plan that was later abandoned.
  • The Geological Survey of India had issued an advisory against building the tunnel through the densely populated hill area.

The Himachal Pradesh High Court has directed the National Highways Authority of India (NHAI) to stop all construction work on the twin-tube tunnel between Chalauthi, Sanjauli, and Bhatta Kuffar. The order follows safety concerns for residential houses located above the tunnel site.

Justice Sandeep Sharma observed that at certain points, including near Vishal Mega Mart and the cemetery, the distance between the tunnel and the ground surface is only 14 metres. The court noted that water is gushing out from both sides of the tunnel.

The construction has already caused cracks in residential houses, and some buildings have been declared unsafe. The Geological Survey of India (GSI) had previously issued an advisory against constructing a tunnel through this hill, which is home to hundreds of houses.

Shimla town (5726333362)
File photo: Ryan from Toronto, Canada / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0

The court questioned why NHAI abandoned a previously approved surface highway plan for the Shimla bypass project on NH-05. For that plan, NHAI had acquired land through Chhakrail, Bhatta Kuffar, and Dhalli, spending ₹600 crore on compensation.

Petitioners, including Vineet Sharma and other Sanjauli residents, submitted that 88 families were displaced and their houses demolished during the land acquisition for the surface highway.

Shimla Panorama
File photo: Naomisahay05 / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0

Justice Sandeep Sharma asked NHAI to explain who would be responsible for the ₹600 crore loss to public funds. The court also asked why a tunnel was chosen despite the GSI advisory and noted that NHAI had not provided a plausible justification for abandoning the surface highway.

NHAI had suspended construction work starting 18 September 2026 due to technical concerns and protests from local residents. IIT Roorkee has been conducting a technical review of the tunnel safety.

The court expressed hope that no construction activity would occur until the next hearing. NHAI has been directed to submit a response within two weeks.